Leading Teams to Success: When Styles Clash

Leading Teams to Success: When Styles Clash thumbnail

We recently worked with an organization with two important teams. One was an “operations team,” focused on basic case management—where consistency and steady thruput were important success factors.  The other was a “strategic initiatives team,” focused on developing new approaches for the case management team—new software tools, new research methods and new services.

 

The organization had hired managers with different styles to lead the two teams. The operations manager was direct, clear, no-nonsense and rules-and-regs focused.  She viewed consistency as a key principle—meaning that employees need to stick to a declared time schedule for work; feedback is delivered directly, without “sugarcoating”; and employees are encouraged to follow the policies in place.  The team was delivering, but some bristled under the direct style.

 

The strategic initiatives manager was more appreciative and loose with the rules, with a “lead from behind” style to allow the high-performing team to discover new services and approaches.  She viewed this approach as demonstrating trust in the team, fostering loyalty and commitment.  This team was also delivering, though not with the focus and accountability that the organization’s senior leaders wanted.

A lot was working with the different managerial styles—both teams were delivering, and both leaders viewed themselves as being authentic, while being aligned with the team’s specific needs.

However, the teams had started to work more closely together for better integration—and the differences were starting to get in the way.  The strategic initiatives team reacted poorly to the directness of the operations manager on joint projects, and the operations team reacted poorly to the loose, unstructured approach of the strategic initiative’s manager. The operation team also resented the freedoms given to the strategic team that they did not also get.

Despite their style differences, the two managers saw the problems, and were able to communicate effectively with each other, so they came together to negotiate some core ground rules.

  • The two managers agreed that a lack of perceived fairness in work schedules was hurting morale. The strategic initiative managers agreed to tighten up expectations, which she acknowledged had strayed beyond organizational guidelines.
  • The operations manager acknowledged that while she wanted to be clear with her feedback, she saw the value in the strategic initiative manager’s more appreciative tone. She started delivering more positive feedback, even when she thought people were “just doing their jobs.”
  • Neither leader wanted to compromise their approaches to deadline management given the differences in their work, but they did agree to set agreed-upon deadline on shared projects being worked on by both teams.
  • The organization’s senior leaders decided they needed to be clearer with the strategic initiatives team about their expectations—that tightened up their work, while allowing the existing leader to exercise her style within clearer boundaries.

This type of case study happens all the time in organizations—thinking about what you would do in this situation may help you in leading your own teams to success!

PRYOR+ 7-DAY FREE TRIAL


Experience 7-days of unlimited learning, then reap the benefits from a year of training at one low price. No credit card. No commitment. Individuals and teams.


Choose a Seminar and Save $10:

Transitioning to Supervisor

Transitioning to Supervisor

Aug. 15

Central Time Zone

Aug. 16

Pacific Time Zone

Aug. 23

Central Time Zone

Aug. 24

Central Time Zone

Aug. 25

Eastern Time Zone

Aug. 29

Pacific Time Zone

Aug. 31

Central Time Zone

Sep. 7

Central Time Zone

Sep. 9

Eastern Time Zone

Sep. 12

Central Time Zone

Sep. 14

Central Time Zone

Sep. 15

Pacific Time Zone

Sep. 19

Eastern Time Zone

Sep. 20

Central Time Zone

Sep. 21

Pacific Time Zone

Sep. 27

Eastern Time Zone

Sep. 29

Central Time Zone

Sep. 30

Pacific Time Zone

Oct. 3

Central Time Zone

Oct. 5

Central Time Zone

Oct. 6

Eastern Time Zone

Oct. 11

Pacific Time Zone

Oct. 13

Central Time Zone

Oct. 14

Eastern Time Zone

Oct. 18

Eastern Time Zone

Oct. 19

Central Time Zone

Oct. 20

Central Time Zone

Oct. 24

Pacific Time Zone

Oct. 25

Central Time Zone

Oct. 26

Eastern Time Zone

Oct. 31

Eastern Time Zone

Nov. 3

Pacific Time Zone

Nov. 4

Central Time Zone

Nov. 8

Eastern Time Zone

Nov. 9

Pacific Time Zone

Nov. 10

Central Time Zone

Nov. 14

Pacific Time Zone

Nov. 16

Eastern Time Zone

Nov. 18

Central Time Zone

Nov. 28

Pacific Time Zone

Nov. 30

Eastern Time Zone

Dec. 2

Central Time Zone

Dec. 6

Pacific Time Zone

Dec. 7

Eastern Time Zone

Dec. 8

Central Time Zone

Dec. 13

Eastern Time Zone

Dec. 15

Central Time Zone

Dec. 16

Pacific Time Zone

Dec. 19

Eastern Time Zone

Dec. 21

Central Time Zone

Leadership, Team-Building and Coaching Skills for Managers and Supervisors

Leadership, Team-Building and Coaching Skills for Managers and Supervisors

Aug. 16

Central Time Zone

Aug. 17

Eastern Time Zone

Aug. 22

Central Time Zone

Aug. 23

Central Time Zone

Aug. 26

Pacific Time Zone

Aug. 31

Central Time Zone

Sep. 1

Eastern Time Zone

Sep. 7

Central Time Zone

Sep. 9

Pacific Time Zone

Sep. 14

Central Time Zone

Sep. 15

Central Time Zone

Sep. 16

Eastern Time Zone

Sep. 19

Central Time Zone

Sep. 20

Central Time Zone

Sep. 26

Pacific Time Zone

Sep. 27

Central Time Zone

Sep. 29

Eastern Time Zone

Oct. 3

Central Time Zone

Oct. 5

Eastern Time Zone

Oct. 7

Pacific Time Zone

Oct. 13

Central Time Zone

Oct. 14

Eastern Time Zone

Oct. 18

Eastern Time Zone

Oct. 20

Pacific Time Zone

Oct. 21

Central Time Zone

Oct. 24

Central Time Zone

Oct. 25

Central Time Zone

Oct. 26

Eastern Time Zone

Oct. 31

Pacific Time Zone

Nov. 1

Central Time Zone

Nov. 3

Eastern Time Zone

Nov. 7

Central Time Zone

Nov. 8

Eastern Time Zone

Nov. 9

Pacific Time Zone

Nov. 16

Central Time Zone

Nov. 17

Pacific Time Zone

Nov. 18

Eastern Time Zone

Nov. 28

Central Time Zone

Dec. 1

Eastern Time Zone

Dec. 2

Pacific Time Zone

Dec. 4

Eastern Time Zone

Dec. 6

Central Time Zone

Dec. 7

Pacific Time Zone

Dec. 15

Pacific Time Zone

Dec. 16

Central Time Zone

Dec. 19

Central Time Zone

Dec. 21

Eastern Time Zone

A Crash Course for the First-Time Manager or Supervisor

A Crash Course for the First-Time Manager or Supervisor

Aug. 18

Central Time Zone

Aug. 19

Pacific Time Zone

Aug. 25

Central Time Zone

Aug. 26

Eastern Time Zone

Aug. 29

Pacific Time Zone

Aug. 31

Central Time Zone

Sep. 7

Central Time Zone

Sep. 13

Eastern Time Zone

Sep. 15

Pacific Time Zone

Sep. 16

Central Time Zone

Sep. 19

Central Time Zone

Sep. 22

Central Time Zone

Sep. 26

Central Time Zone

Sep. 27

Pacific Time Zone

Sep. 28

Eastern Time Zone

Oct. 5

Eastern Time Zone

Oct. 7

Central Time Zone

Oct. 12

Central Time Zone

Oct. 13

Central Time Zone

Oct. 17

Central Time Zone

Oct. 18

Pacific Time Zone

Oct. 25

Eastern Time Zone

Oct. 27

Central Time Zone

Oct. 28

Pacific Time Zone

Oct. 31

Central Time Zone

Nov. 1

Eastern Time Zone

Nov. 9

Eastern Time Zone

Nov. 16

Pacific Time Zone

Nov. 17

Central Time Zone

Nov. 29

Eastern Time Zone

Dec. 1

Central Time Zone

Dec. 5

Pacific Time Zone

Dec. 8

Central Time Zone

Dec. 13

Central Time Zone

Dec. 14

Pacific Time Zone

Dec. 21

Eastern Time Zone

Management & Leadership Skills for New Managers and Supervisors (2-Day)

Management & Leadership Skills for New Managers and Supervisors (2-Day)

Aug. 15

Eastern Time Zone

Aug. 18

Central Time Zone

Aug. 22

Pacific Time Zone

Aug. 24

Central Time Zone

Aug. 30

Eastern Time Zone

Sep. 7

Pacific Time Zone

Sep. 13

Central Time Zone

Sep. 15

Eastern Time Zone

Sep. 19

Pacific Time Zone

Sep. 22

Central Time Zone

Sep. 26

Central Time Zone

Sep. 28

Eastern Time Zone

Oct. 3

Eastern Time Zone

Oct. 5

Pacific Time Zone

Oct. 11

Central Time Zone

Oct. 13

Eastern Time Zone

Oct. 18

Pacific Time Zone

Oct. 20

Central Time Zone

Oct. 24

Eastern Time Zone

Oct. 26

Central Time Zone

Nov. 1

Pacific Time Zone

Nov. 3

Central Time Zone

Nov. 7

Pacific Time Zone

Nov. 9

Eastern Time Zone

Nov. 14

Eastern Time Zone

Nov. 16

Central Time Zone

Nov. 29

Eastern Time Zone

Dec. 1

Central Time Zone

Dec. 5

Eastern Time Zone

Dec. 8

Pacific Time Zone

Dec. 12

Central Time Zone

Dec. 14

Pacific Time Zone

Dec. 20

Central Time Zone

How to Supervise People

How to Supervise People

Aug. 18

Pacific Time Zone

Aug. 24

Eastern Time Zone

Aug. 26

Central Time Zone

Aug. 29

Central Time Zone

Sep. 8

Eastern Time Zone

Sep. 12

Pacific Time Zone

Sep. 15

Central Time Zone

Sep. 21

Eastern Time Zone

Sep. 23

Central Time Zone

Sep. 27

Central Time Zone

Sep. 28

Pacific Time Zone

Oct. 3

Central Time Zone

Oct. 4

Central Time Zone

Oct. 13

Eastern Time Zone

Oct. 14

Central Time Zone

Oct. 21

Pacific Time Zone

Oct. 26

Eastern Time Zone

Oct. 27

Central Time Zone

Nov. 2

Eastern Time Zone

Nov. 3

Central Time Zone

Nov. 7

Pacific Time Zone

Nov. 15

Central Time Zone

Nov. 17

Eastern Time Zone

Nov. 29

Central Time Zone

Dec. 1

Pacific Time Zone

Dec. 6

Pacific Time Zone

Dec. 7

Eastern Time Zone

Dec. 15

Eastern Time Zone

Dec. 19

Central Time Zone

How to Supervise Bad Attitudes and Negative Behaviors

How to Supervise Bad Attitudes and Negative Behaviors

Aug. 17

Central Time Zone

Aug. 18

Eastern Time Zone

Aug. 22

Central Time Zone

Aug. 23

Eastern Time Zone

Aug. 30

Central Time Zone

Sep. 7

Central Time Zone

Sep. 15

Eastern Time Zone

Sep. 16

Central Time Zone

Sep. 20

Pacific Time Zone

Sep. 30

Central Time Zone

Oct. 5

Central Time Zone

Oct. 12

Pacific Time Zone

Oct. 21

Central Time Zone

Oct. 27

Eastern Time Zone

Nov. 1

Central Time Zone

Nov. 10

Eastern Time Zone

Nov. 15

Pacific Time Zone

Nov. 16

Central Time Zone

Nov. 30

Pacific Time Zone

Dec. 6

Eastern Time Zone

Dec. 8

Central Time Zone

Dec. 12

Eastern Time Zone

Dec. 13

Central Time Zone

How Managers Become Great Leaders

How Managers Become Great Leaders

Aug. 17

Central Time Zone

Aug. 23

Central Time Zone

Aug. 31

Eastern Time Zone

Sep. 8

Central Time Zone

Sep. 14

Pacific Time Zone

Sep. 20

Eastern Time Zone

Sep. 21

Central Time Zone

Sep. 27

Central Time Zone

Oct. 5

Pacific Time Zone

Oct. 12

Central Time Zone

Oct. 18

Eastern Time Zone

Oct. 21

Central Time Zone

Oct. 27

Central Time Zone

Nov. 1

Central Time Zone

Nov. 9

Eastern Time Zone

Nov. 15

Pacific Time Zone

Nov. 17

Central Time Zone

Dec. 1

Central Time Zone

Dec. 2

Eastern Time Zone

Dec. 5

Central Time Zone

Dec. 6

Pacific Time Zone

Dec. 14

Eastern Time Zone

Leadership & Management Skills for Women

Leadership & Management Skills for Women

Aug. 16

Central Time Zone

Aug. 16

Central Time Zone

Aug. 25

Central Time Zone

Aug. 25

Central Time Zone

Sep. 9

Central Time Zone

Sep. 9

Central Time Zone

Sep. 13

Central Time Zone

Sep. 13

Central Time Zone

Sep. 21

Central Time Zone

Sep. 21

Central Time Zone

Sep. 29

Central Time Zone

Sep. 29

Central Time Zone

Oct. 4

Central Time Zone

Oct. 4

Central Time Zone

Oct. 13

Central Time Zone

Oct. 13

Central Time Zone

Oct. 20

Central Time Zone

Oct. 20

Central Time Zone

Oct. 26

Central Time Zone

Oct. 26

Central Time Zone

Nov. 1

Central Time Zone

Nov. 1

Central Time Zone

Nov. 9

Central Time Zone

Nov. 9

Central Time Zone

Nov. 10

Central Time Zone

Nov. 10

Central Time Zone

Nov. 14

Central Time Zone

Nov. 14

Central Time Zone

Nov. 30

Central Time Zone

Nov. 30

Central Time Zone

Dec. 1

Central Time Zone

Dec. 1

Central Time Zone

Dec. 6

Central Time Zone

Dec. 6

Central Time Zone

Dec. 13

Central Time Zone

Dec. 13

Central Time Zone

Dec. 15

Central Time Zone

Dec. 15

Central Time Zone

Employment Laws All Managers Need to Know

Employment Laws All Managers Need to Know

Aug. 17

Central Time Zone

Aug. 25

Central Time Zone

Aug. 30

Eastern Time Zone

Nov. 3

Central Time Zone

Nov. 7

Central Time Zone

Nov. 8

Eastern Time Zone

Nov. 16

Pacific Time Zone

Nov. 28

Central Time Zone

Nov. 30

Pacific Time Zone

Dec. 6

Central Time Zone

Dec. 7

Eastern Time Zone

Dec. 15

Eastern Time Zone

The Management Conference

The Management Conference

Oct. 5

Central Time Zone

Oct. 11

Eastern Time Zone

Oct. 20

Pacific Time Zone

Oct. 24

Central Time Zone

Oct. 31

Central Time Zone

Nov. 2

Eastern Time Zone

Nov. 8

Central Time Zone

Nov. 17

Pacific Time Zone

Nov. 29

Central Time Zone

Dec. 8

Eastern Time Zone

Dec. 12

Pacific Time Zone

Dec. 14

Central Time Zone

Inspiring Employee Motivation and Engagement

Inspiring Employee Motivation and Engagement

Aug. 17

Central Time Zone

Aug. 17

Central Time Zone

Aug. 23

Central Time Zone

Aug. 23

Central Time Zone

Aug. 31

Central Time Zone

Aug. 31

Central Time Zone

Nov. 3

Central Time Zone

Nov. 3

Central Time Zone

Nov. 9

Central Time Zone

Nov. 9

Central Time Zone

Nov. 15

Central Time Zone

Nov. 15

Central Time Zone

Nov. 16

Central Time Zone

Nov. 16

Central Time Zone

Nov. 29

Central Time Zone

Nov. 29

Central Time Zone

Dec. 7

Central Time Zone

Dec. 7

Central Time Zone

Dec. 8

Central Time Zone

Dec. 8

Central Time Zone

Dec. 14

Central Time Zone

Dec. 14

Central Time Zone

Criticism & Discipline Skills for Managers and Supervisors

Criticism & Discipline Skills for Managers and Supervisors

Aug. 16

Central Time Zone

Aug. 31

Eastern Time Zone

Sep. 8

Eastern Time Zone

Sep. 14

Central Time Zone

Sep. 20

Eastern Time Zone

Sep. 29

Central Time Zone

Nov. 29

Pacific Time Zone

Dec. 6

Central Time Zone

Dec. 14

Central Time Zone

Dec. 15

Eastern Time Zone

Managing with Assertive Confidence

Managing with Assertive Confidence

Aug. 16

Pacific Time Zone

Aug. 23

Central Time Zone

Sep. 13

Central Time Zone

Sep. 22

Central Time Zone

Sep. 23

Eastern Time Zone

Sep. 28

Central Time Zone

Nov. 28

Eastern Time Zone

Dec. 7

Central Time Zone

Dec. 8

Pacific Time Zone

Dec. 13

Central Time Zone

Facilities Management - A 2-Day Comprehensive Course

Facilities Management - A 2-Day Comprehensive Course

Aug. 17

Eastern Time Zone

Aug. 23

Central Time Zone

Sep. 15

Central Time Zone

Sep. 20

Eastern Time Zone

Sep. 26

Pacific Time Zone

Dec. 1

Pacific Time Zone

Dec. 6

Central Time Zone

Dec. 12

Eastern Time Zone

Dec. 14

Central Time Zone

Be the Manager Your Employees Want to Follow

Be the Manager Your Employees Want to Follow

Sep. 9

Central Time Zone

Sep. 13

Pacific Time Zone

Sep. 22

Eastern Time Zone

Sep. 28

Central Time Zone

Oct. 4

Central Time Zone

Oct. 12

Pacific Time Zone

Oct. 19

Central Time Zone

Oct. 27

Eastern Time Zone

Creative Leadership

Creative Leadership

Sep. 14

Eastern Time Zone

Sep. 15

Central Time Zone

Sep. 20

Central Time Zone

Sep. 29

Pacific Time Zone

Oct. 6

Central Time Zone

Oct. 12

Eastern Time Zone

Oct. 18

Central Time Zone

Oct. 27

Pacific Time Zone

How to Improve Employee Accountability with Remote and In-Person Teams

How to Improve Employee Accountability with Remote and In-Person Teams

Oct. 4

Central Time Zone

Oct. 12

Eastern Time Zone

Oct. 20

Central Time Zone

Oct. 26

Pacific Time Zone

Nov. 2

Eastern Time Zone

Nov. 8

Central Time Zone

Nov. 10

Pacific Time Zone

Nov. 17

Central Time Zone

The Exceptional Team Leader

The Exceptional Team Leader

Oct. 4

Pacific Time Zone

Oct. 13

Central Time Zone

Oct. 19

Eastern Time Zone

Oct. 28

Central Time Zone

Nov. 2

Central Time Zone

Nov. 8

Central Time Zone

Nov. 10

Eastern Time Zone

Nov. 17

Pacific Time Zone

Basic Accounting Skills for the Business Professional

Basic Accounting Skills for the Business Professional

Oct. 7

Eastern Time Zone

Oct. 12

Central Time Zone

Oct. 18

Pacific Time Zone

Oct. 27

Central Time Zone

Oct. 31

Central Time Zone

Nov. 10

Pacific Time Zone

Nov. 15

Eastern Time Zone

Overcoming Negativity

Overcoming Negativity

Oct. 4

Eastern Time Zone

Oct. 14

Central Time Zone

Oct. 20

Pacific Time Zone

Oct. 26

Central Time Zone

Nov. 3

Eastern Time Zone

Nov. 9

Pacific Time Zone

Nov. 15

Central Time Zone

Managing Virtual Employees

Managing Virtual Employees

Aug. 17

Central Time Zone

Aug. 17

Central Time Zone

Aug. 25

Central Time Zone

Aug. 25

Central Time Zone

Sep. 13

Central Time Zone

Sep. 13

Central Time Zone

Sep. 20

Central Time Zone

Sep. 20

Central Time Zone

Sep. 21

Central Time Zone

Sep. 21

Central Time Zone

Sep. 29

Central Time Zone

Sep. 29

Central Time Zone

The Indispensable Office Manager

The Indispensable Office Manager

Aug. 23

Central Time Zone

Aug. 31

Pacific Time Zone

Sep. 13

Eastern Time Zone

Sep. 15

Central Time Zone

Sep. 22

Pacific Time Zone

Sep. 28

Central Time Zone

Coaching Skills and Leadership Lessons

Coaching Skills and Leadership Lessons

Oct. 5

Central Time Zone

Oct. 5

Central Time Zone

Oct. 11

Central Time Zone

Oct. 11

Central Time Zone

Oct. 18

Central Time Zone

Oct. 18

Central Time Zone

Oct. 27

Central Time Zone

Oct. 27

Central Time Zone

Related Management, Supervision & Leadership Articles

PRYOR+ 7-DAY FREE TRIAL


Experience 7-days of unlimited learning, then reap the benefits from a year of training at one low price. No credit card. No commitment. Individuals and teams.

Categories